Introduction : modernist, orthodox, or flexidox? : why the culture war debate endures / E. J. Dionne, Jr. and Michael Cromartie -- The enduring culture war / James Davison Hunter -- The culture war that never came / Alan Wolfe -- Comment : the other culture war / Gertrude Himmelfarb -- Comment : further reflections on the culture war thesis / Morris P. Fiorina -- A response / James Davison Hunter -- A response / Alan Wolfe