Introduction / Ronald Dworkin -- 1. Early Responses / Ronald Dworkin -- 2. Lawless Order and Hot Cases / Cass R. Sunstein -- 3. Freeing eroG v. hsuB From its Hall of Mirrors / Laurence H. Tribe -- 4. Constitutionalizing Democratic Politics / Richard H. Pildes -- 5. Bush v. Gore as Pragmatic Adjudication / Richard A. Posner -- 6. How to Democratize American Democracy / Arthur Schlesinger, Jr. -- 7. And to the C students: The Lessons of Bush v. Gore / Lani Guinier -- 8. Holy Cow! Preliminary Reflections on the 2000 Election / Nelson W. Polsby