Limit search to available items
Record 22 of 29
Previous Record Next Record
Author Ṣāyigh, Yazīd

Title Policing the people, building the state : authoritarian transformation in the West Bank and Gaza / Yezid Sayigh
Published Washington, DC : Carnegie Endowment for International Peace, 2011
Online access available from:
JSTOR Security    View Resource Record  


Description 1 online resource (32 pages) : illustrations (digital, PDF file)
Series Carnegie papers
Working papers (Carnegie Endowment for International Peace)
Contents Summary -- Policing the people, building the state -- The reform agenda -- Authoritarian transformation -- The challenges ahead
Summary As rival governments in the West Bank and Gaza have sought to strengthen their respective Palestinian Authority Security Force (PASF) sectors in recent years, they have adopted very different approaches. The Fayyad government in the West Bank largely relies on financial and training support from the West, while the Haniah government of Hamas in Gaza, lacking significant outside help, has been forced to streamline its operations. Although well-intentioned, Western efforts have hindered, rather than helped, West Bank forces, who have received almost $450 million in assistance from the United States and the European Union since 2007. The West's limited focus on technical assistance rather than governance and institution building and its disjointed overall approach, along with the lack of coherence and autonomy in the West Bank PASF, are largely responsible for the sector's failure to develop its own training and planning capabilities. The Gaza PASF, on the other hand, has benefited from the absence of external support. Hamas, rather than outside donors, chooses how to design its policies and programs and set its priorities. As a result of this sense of ownership, its security sector is more integrated, has a clearer chain of command, and has developed more professional training and planning capabilities than the West Bank sector. But the fundamental problem in both regions is that security sector rebuilding and restructuring occurs without democratic governance and a constitutional order. While the Fayyad government in the West Bank and the Haniah government in Gaza publicly stress a strict adherence to the rule of law and genuine observance of human rights, their lack of constitutional checks and balances, especially weak legislative and judicial oversight, makes this difficult. Civilian control of the security forces is also growing more tenuous, especially as political infighting grows in the West Bank and Islamization increases in Gaza. This trend will continue unless a number of steps are taken. These include achieving Palestinian "ownership" of security sector development--especially in the West Bank--reintegrating the West Bank and Gaza PASF, assuring government control of security in both areas, and designing a new national security vision by engaging all relevant stakeholders. Otherwise, growing authoritarianism in both regions will threaten not only their long-term security but also the ability to achieve Palestinian statehood
Notes "February 2011."
Title from PDF title page (viewed on April 4, 2011)
Bibliography Includes bibliographical references (pages 27-28)
Subject Security sector -- Gaza Strip
Security sector -- West Bank
Technical assistance -- West Bank
Politics and government
Security sector.
Technical assistance.
Gaza Strip -- Politics and government
West Bank -- Politics and government
Gaza Strip.
West Bank.
Form Electronic book
Author Carnegie Middle East Center