Limit search to available items
Book Cover
E-book
Author Smart, Harry W

Title Criticism and Public Rationality : Professional Rigidity and the Search for Caring Government
Published Hoboken : Taylor and Francis, 2013

Copies

Description 1 online resource (421 pages)
Series Routledge Revivals
Routledge revivals.
Contents Cover; Half Title; Title Page; Copyright Page; Original Title Page; Original Copyright Page; Table of Contents; Acknowledgements; Introduction: rationality and power; The organisation of the book; 1. A rational response to deprivation; Strathclyde: criticism within the local authority; Rationalising deprivation: Coventry CDP; Rationalising rationality: the Positivist Dispute; Criticism: the unwritten rules; The breakdown of criticism: an hypothesis; 2. Strathclyde: management structures; The Local Government (Scotland) Act 1973; The Paterson Report; Paterson: key elements of structure
Paterson and the professionals: summaryStrathclyde: review of departmental structures; 3. Strathclyde: deprivation policy development; The national background; The local background: Clydeside; Strathclyde Regional Council; 4. Traditions of rationality; Classical thought; The Judaeo-Christian tradition; The Enlightenment; 5. The Positivist Dispute; The Frankfurt School: the critical theory of society; Popper and the problem of method; Identifying the three philosophies; 6. Strathclyde policy documents: text and exposition; Introduction; Gilding the Ghetto; Strathclyde texts
Exposition: the Red Book and AoNCoda: Physical Planning and Policy Planning; 7. Interview texts and exposition; Introduction; Jarndyce; Texts; Exposition: interview texts; 8. Conclusions: the breakdown of criticism; The texts compared; Explaining Jarndyce; Public rationality; Coda; The importance of language and process; What was the Region trying to do?; Can local government ever deliver?; Notes and references; Index
Summary Criticism is at the heart of any political discussion, and criticism of old policies is central to the development of new ones. In its analysis of political decision-making, this reissue, first published in 1991, examines the principles which control the process of policy criticism. It identifies two fundamental and related obstacles to this process: the privileged status accorded to 'professional judgement' and the conflicting philosophical ideas that shape political argument. Based on the study of Europe's largest local authority, the book presents a theory of decision-making that can be
Notes Print version record
Subject Strathclyde (Scotland). Regional Council.
SUBJECT Strathclyde (Scotland). Regional Council fast
Subject Local government -- Scotland -- Strathclyde -- Decision making
Urban policy -- Scotland -- Strathclyde
POLITICAL SCIENCE -- Public Affairs & Administration.
Local government -- Decision making
Urban policy
Scotland -- Strathclyde
Form Electronic book
ISBN 9781317831105
1317831101
9781317831112
131783111X